

The question is often asked of myself or our fantastic AT Specialists, “What is the best kind of switch?” The answer will always be the same – “The one that works for that individual!” As we assess the types of switches out there, we need to recognize that all switches are not alike. Even within types of switches, we need to think of them like types of apples. There are different types which people prefer and can be used for different things. Think of it this way, a Granny Smith apple might be good for baking a pie or those of us who like a tart apple. A Red Delicious is sweeter and makes for a great snack. They are both apples, just liked by different people and able to be used in different ways.
In this blog, we are going to focus on the following types of switches: standard, proximity, and wireless. We are going to focus our next blog on specialized switches. Within the category of specialized, we will look at a number of different switches which can be used for specific situations. Any of the switches I am discussing here or next month, I have used and received feedback on from our colleagues in the field. I am going to stay away from discussing homemade switches as the stories around them are dependent upon so many variables. There are also inconsistencies within how they are manufactured that does not always allow for generalizations. Don’t get me wrong, some of them are well designed and work well. However, there is not a solid track record due to not having a set way of manufacturing.
Let’s start with standard switches. When I say standard switches, I am referring to a simple press down switch like an AbleNet Jelly Bean. These are switches that can be used for a number of purposes but do require the user to have enough fine motor skills to press down on them. Since I began with an AbleNet switch, let’s stay with them as a manufacturer. AbleNet has the Jelly Bean, the Buddy Button, the Big Buddy Button, the Big Red, and the Specs IC that operate in the same way. There are differences within each that lend themselves to certain situations. For example, the Jelly Bean can be mounted and is a strong go-to when it comes to a switch that can be used for a number of activities. It’s 2.5-inch surface allows the user to have a nice-sized area with which to connect. If the individual needs a larger area for connection, the Big Red provides a 5-inch surface to assist those individuals who need the larger area. The Buddy Button helps those individuals who need to be able to activate a switch with a lighter touch. For those with moderate to severe upper extremity and motor issues, moving to the Big Buddy Button offers higher levels of access and potential success in activation. The Specs IC, with its 1 and 3/8-inch surface offers a smaller footprint for individuals who need to use a switch and have strong fine motor control.
Pretorian has the Smoothie Switch which is great for those individuals who may only have the ability to touch along a side of the switch for activation. They use the same style for their Simply Works switches as well. If you have an individual who is rough on switches or may have some drooling issues, then the Piko Button would be a likely choice. The water-resistant switch allows that individual to continue to use a switch even if they are getting it wet. Enabling Devices has the Gumball Switch which is good standard type of switch with its 2 ½-inch surface. For those who need something a little smaller, their 11/4-inch compact switch works well and they even include Velcro to use as a mount. For those who need something a little larger, their Jumbo switch fits the bill giving a larger area for contact.
When we look at proximity switches, we want to recognize what they do and how they can be best utilized. The AbleNet Candy Corn is the best known of the proximity switches. It does come in only the big size now. It also has the ability to have both sound and lights on or off to acknowledge activation. I still recommend this switch as a head or cheek switch alternative. Adaptivation has created the Honey Bee Switch which combines both proximity and touch into a single switch. This is great for OTs who are working on fine motor skills and touch abilities. Another one of my favorites is the Movement Sensor Switch from Enabling Devices. This switch can be adjusted to pick up even the slightest fluctuation of a digit to activate the switch. We wrap up the proximity switch section with one from Pretorian which also is a Bluetooth wireless switch and that is the ToFFEE BT. This switch gives the flexibility of having both proximity features along with being wireless.
When we look at wireless switches, we need to know what we are connecting to as well. For example, when connecting to an iPad, the AbleNet Blue2 stands out as it was the first switch to connect to this device. The current version also has light touch and lights up to show activation. AbleNet also has the Jelly Beamer and the Big Beamer for those situations where you want to move an individual from a Jelly Bean or Big Red which are connected via a wire to a wireless option. The switches look similar, have the same surface area, and allow the user to feel comfortable with the change.
There are other specialized switches which fit into these categories as well. I am going to keep those for next month though as there is a lot to discuss around them as sometimes we need to make sure it is something that can accommodate the needs and strengths of our individuals. There may be some switches which I have not mentioned here as well. That is due to either no experiences with them or less than satisfactory experiences. The switches that are a part of this blog have strong track records and have helped many individuals. As always, if you have any questions, feel free to reach out to me at rheipp@schoolhealth.com.




















